The efficacy of transitioning kids in America has always been asserted with faith and not facts.
As the rest of the world continues to backpedal, this becomes more and more clear.
— Chloe Cole ⭐️ (@ChoooCole) April 13, 2024
A study, you say?
Studies are very important in determining things that are obvious to everyone.
A study which finds gender-confused youth mostly grow out of it and a ban on puberty blockers in England are both being hailed as “vindication” by “detransitioners” — people who have gone back to their birth sex after transitioning as teenagers.
Detransitioners told The Post that they were living evidence for a major study in the Netherlands which found that what psychiatrists refer to as “gender dysphoria” — a desire to be the opposite sex — diminishes significantly between adolescence and early adulthood.
And the also backed a report in England where doctors were told to stop prescribing “puberty blocking” hormones after a bombshell audit of the country’s leading gender clinic, the Tavistock in London, found troubled teens were given the drugs without medical evidence that they were safe.
“These revelations are hugely vindicating,” 19-year-old detransitioner Chloe Cole told The Post.
“It’s frustrating that it has taken this long, but I’m thankful that this is finally becoming a mainstream conversation, and people are finally starting to wake up to what we are doing to children.”
In the Dutch study researchers tracked 2,700 children over the course of 15 years. They found that 11% of kids were struggling with their gender in early adolescence.
But by the age of 26, that number plummeted to 4% because, as the researchers note, “gender non-contentedness, while being relatively common during early adolescence, in general decreases with age.”
…
Detransitioner Airiel Salvatore, 34 of Seattle, said he was “not surprised at all” that the study found the majority of gender-questioning kids end up comfortable with their birth gender.
“That totally comports with my experience, given what I observed among a lot of my transgender friends,” Salvatore, who began hormone treatments in 2005 and underwent genital reassignment surgery in 2014 before detransitioning last year, told The Post.
“Europe seems to be ahead of the curve,” he said. “It seems that here the clinics are more ideologically captured. It’s almost like they don’t want to know the answer because this whole entire thing is really just running on maladaptive empathy.”
Fellow detransitioner Cole — who came out as transgender at 13, had a double mastectomy at 15, and ultimately detransitioned by age 16 — agrees America is also falling behind in realizing the medicalization of trans youth has been a mistake.
So far England, Finland, Sweden, Norway, and Denmark have all moved to limit medical intervention in transgender youth.
But in the United States it has become a hot-button culture war issue, with progressive states like New York and California declaring themselves “safe havens” for trans kids seeking treatment.
Frankly, anyone who needs a study to tell them this is too far gone to be convinced by a study.
That’s why none of these studies change anyone’s mind.
You have to be really, really extreme to support mutilating children with injections and surgeries.
If you’re that far gone, no study is going to sway you.
At the same time as youth gender transitions became widely available, the numbers of referred gender distressed youth began to rapidly grow. Unexpectedly, the profile shifted from mostly young boys, to mostly adolescent females with serious mental health problems.
It was clear… pic.twitter.com/3B5Ik7Vxcs
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024
Also, nearly all treated with puberty blockers proceeded to cross-sex hormones. Rather than providing “time to think,” they were cementing a desire to transition. As Dr. Hutchinson put it, “What are the chances if 100% of people offered time to think, thinking the same thing”?… pic.twitter.com/zZSfhM2nhS
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024
Another key lesson from the UK is about powerful special interest groups exerting influence on clinical practice. In the UK, one of such groups which strongly pushed for wide availability of youth transitions is @Mermaids_Gender. Similar activist groups are currently exerting… pic.twitter.com/jA6T0ZPOU1
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024
Lesson 5, “informed consent,” is particularly poignant at the present moment. Young people treated with puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries, need to know the full range of profound risks and uncertainties–instead of being misled into believing that they are… pic.twitter.com/u6c3K8vqWt
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024
Finally, lesson 7 emphasizes the need for robust data. Gender medicine should not be an exception to the standards of evidence-based medicine. “It’s not acceptable that this group of children and young people have a lower standard of care, follow-up, and evidence-based treatment… pic.twitter.com/a5KQpZohsW
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024
This week, England prepares for the release of the final Cass review, with the rest of the world watching. The final details of the Cass recommendations are not yet known. Nor is it known whether and how NHS England will follow these recommendations. But one thing is clear.… pic.twitter.com/qytfGY3h4V
— SEGM (@segm_ebm) April 8, 2024